Reflecting
IB Presentation on Reflecting on the Personal Project
IB Presentation on Reflecting on the Personal Project
Checklists and Reflections for the Paper Sections of the Personal Project
Criterion A: Self Evaluation of the Planning Section of the Personal Project Paper
Criterion B: Self Evaluation of Applying ATL Skills to the Learning and Product
Criterion C: Self Evaluation of Reflection, Personal Project Paper
Evaluating Goals and Product
When evaluating the product students should use their success criteria. Students should gather evidence to show the success of the product. Their evaluation should focus on what extent they achieved their goal.
When evaluating the impact of the project (both the learning goal and the product), students might talk about how it impacted them personally or how it impacted others.
Reflection Prompts
SUCCESS CRITERIA
Were my success criteria too easy or too difficult?
What could I have done differently to make my product better reflect my success criteria?
To what extent did I complete my product based on the success criteria?
How can I demonstrate that I completed my product based on my success criteria?
What are my project's strengths?
ATL SKILLS & Learner Profile Traits
How did the ATL skills contribute to my success of learning and of developing the product?
Consider communication (speaking, listening, reading, writing), collaboration skills, self-management (organizational skills, meeting deadlines, creating plan, time management), affective skills (focus and concentration, perseverance, management of stress, self-motivation), reflection (identifying strengths and weaknesses, growth), research (information and media literacy, using technology, synthesizing research, seek a range of perspectives), critical thinking (observations, inferences, conclusions, interpreting data, identify obstacles and challenges, troubleshoot systems and applications), creativity and innovation (solutions, brainstorming, original works and ideas), and transfer skills (applying skills and knowledge cross curricular/across subjects).
What was inside my control and what was outside of my control? How did these factors influence the progress I made? How did I handle challenges during the process and persevere?
What learner profile traits did I enhance through this project?
PROGRESS
What progress did you make in the end toward your learning goal?
GROWTH & DEVELOPMENT
How has your perspective grown or developed through this project?
What have I learned about the subject?
What have I learned about myself through this process?
What skills have I acquired?
What skills have I improved?
What am I most proud of?
How has my point of view changed?
FUTURE IMPLICATIONS
What would I do differently if I had to start again?
How has my project prepared me for the future?
Consider the impact of the learning and the product.
- Possible impacts of the learning goal
Demonstrating and developing ATL skills
Extending knowledge about a topic
Developing confidence as an autonomous learner developing an independent product
- Possible impacts of the product
Meeting a need in the community
Showcasing the skills or abilities of students
Evidence of the ATLs
Students will select which ATLs best helped them with their learning goal and the creation of their product when they write criterion B of their report. Students will provide evidence to show how they used their ATLS.
Evidence might be: visual thinking diagrams, bulleted lists, charts, short paragraphs, notes, timelines, action plans, annotated illustrations, annotated research, artefacts from visits to museums, performances or galleries, pictures, photographs, sketches, up to 30 seconds of visual or audio material, screenshots of a blog of website, self and peer-assessment feedback.
The success of the ATLs
When reflecting on the success of their product and learning goal (criterion C) students may wish to make connections to the ATLs. How did their use of these skills help them be successful? What was most challenging to them? What skill did they develop the most?
Reflecting on the ATLs in Managebac
When writing journal entries in ManageBac, students can select the ATLs which relate to each entry. This will help students to track which skill types they use most and will help them reflect and find evidence of the skills used throughout the project.
What are Approaches to Learning?
In order for students to grow as autonomous learners, the IB Middle Years Programme (MYP) intentionally teaches Approaches to Learning (ATL) skills to help students build on the process of learning.
Communication
Communication: How can students communicate through interaction and demonstrate their communication through language? Students can consider a range of topics such as giving and receiving feedback, oral and written communication, a variety of media, non-verbal communication, digital platforms, purposes and audiences, etc.
Speaking and Listening
Give and receive meaningful feedback
Use intercultural understanding to interpret communication
Use a variety of speaking techniques to communicate with a variety of audiences
Use appropriate forms of writing for different purposes and audiences
Use a variety of media to communicate with a range of audiences
Interpret and use effectively modes of non-verbal communication
Negotiate ideas and knowledge with peers and teachers
Participate in, and contribute to, digital social media networks
Collaborate with peers and experts using a variety of digital environments and media
Share ideas with multiple audiences using a variety of digital environments and media
Reading and Writing
Read critically and for comprehension
Read a variety of sources for information and for pleasure
Make inferences and draw conclusions
Use and interpret a range of discipline-specific terms and symbols
Write for different purposes
Understand and use mathematical notation
Paraphrase accurately and concisely
Preview and skim texts to build understanding
Take effective notes in class
Make effective summary notes for studying
Use a variety of organizers for academic writing tasks
Find information for disciplinary and interdisciplinary inquiries, using a variety of media
Organize and depict information logically
Structure information in summaries, essays and reports
Social
Collaboration Skills: How can students collaborate effectively with one another? Students can consider a range of topics such as social media, empathy, delegation and shared responsibility, resolving conflict, building consensus, negotiating, encouraging others to contribute, giving and receiving feedback, etc.?
Use social media networks appropriately to build and develop relationships
Practise empathy
Delegate and share responsibility for decision-making
Help others to succeed
Take responsibility for one’s own actions
Manage and resolve conflict, and work collaboratively in teams
Build consensus
Make fair and equitable decisions
Listen actively to other perspectives and ideas
Negotiate effectively
Encourage others to contribute
Exercise leadership and take on a variety of roles within groups
Give and receive meaningful feedback
Advocate for one’s own rights and needs
Self Management
Organization Skills: How can students manage time and tasks effectively to enhance their organizational skills? Students can consider a range of topics such as short vs long term assignments, meeting deadlines, calendar, goal setting, system of information, digital tools, learning styles, etc.?
Plan short- and long-term assignments; meet deadlines
Create plans to prepare for summative assessments (examinations and performances)
Keep and use a weekly planner for assignments
Set goals that are challenging and realistic
Plan strategies and take action to achieve personal and academic goals
Bring necessary equipment and supplies to class
Keep an organized and logical system of information files/notebooks
Use appropriate strategies for organizing complex information
Understand and use sensory learning preferences (learning styles)
Select and use technology effectively and productively
Affective Skills: How can students manage their own state of mind in order to be healthy and productive contributors to society? Students can consider a range of topics such as practicing mindfulness (concentration and mental breaks to sharpen focus), perseverance (practicing patience and persistence), emotional management (practicing peace and calm and being aware of emotions), self motivation (practicing positive thinking and a growth mindset), and resilience (practicing bouncing back after mistakes and failures and dealing with disappointment or change).
Mindfulness awareness
Practise focus and concentration
Practise strategies to develop mental focus
Practise strategies to overcome distractions
Practise being aware of body–mind connections
Perseverance
Demonstrate persistence and perseverance
Practise delaying gratification
Emotional management
Practise strategies to overcome impulsiveness and anger
Practise strategies to prevent and eliminate bullying
Practise strategies to reduce stress and anxiety
Self-motivation
Practise analysing and attributing causes for failure
Practise managing self-talk
Practise positive thinking
Resilience
Practise “bouncing back” after adversity, mistakes and failures
Practise “failing well”
Practise dealing with disappointment and unmet expectations
Practise dealing with change
Reflection: How can students be reflective of their learning? Students can consider a range of topics such as identifying strengths and weaknesses of personal learning strategies and techniques, reflecting on new learning and areas for further exploration or confusion, reviewing the process of learning, etc.
Develop new skills, techniques and strategies for effective learning
Identify strengths and weaknesses of personal learning strategies (self-assessment)
Demonstrate flexibility in the selection and use of learning strategies
Try new ATL skills and evaluate their effectiveness
Consider content
What did I learn about today?
What don’t I yet understand?
What questions do I have now?
Consider ATL skills development
What can I already do?
How can I share my skills to help peers who need more practice?
What will I work on next?
Consider personal learning strategies
What can I do to become a more efficient and effective learner?
How can I become more flexible in my choice of learning strategies?
What factors are important for helping me learn well?
Focus on the process of creating by imitating the work of others
Consider ethical, cultural and environmental implications
Keep a journal to record reflections
Research
Information Literacy: How can students demonstrate information literacy? Students can consider a range of topics such as collecting, recording, and analyzing data; making connections between various sources, analyzing information to make informed decisions, using critical thinking skills to analyze and interpret media communications, and evaluate and select informational tools based on their relevance and appropriateness.
Collect, record and verify data
Access information to be informed and inform others
Make connections between various sources of information
Understand the benefits and limitations of personal sensory learning preferences when accessing, processing and recalling information
Use memory techniques to develop long-term memory
Present information in a variety of formats and platforms
Collect and analyse data to identify solutions and make informed decisions
Process data and report results
Evaluate and select information sources and digital tools based on their appropriateness to specific tasks
Understand and use technology systems
Use critical-literacy skills to analyse and interpret media communications
Understand and implement intellectual property rights
Create references and citations, use footnotes/endnotes and construct a bibliography according to recognized conventions
Identify primary and secondary sources
Media Literacy: How can students demonstrate media literacy? Students can consider a range of topics such as how they interact with media to use and create interpretations of information, seeking a range of perspectives from multiple sources, communicating through various platforms, and seeking to understand connections by comparing and contrasting and evaluating a variety of media and formats.
Locate, organize, analyse, evaluate, synthesize and ethically use information from a variety of sources and media (including digital social media and online networks)
Demonstrate awareness of media interpretations of events and ideas (including digital social media)
Make informed choices about personal viewing experiences
Understand the impact of media representations and modes of presentation
Seek a range of perspectives from multiple and varied sources
Communicate information and ideas effectively to multiple audiences using a variety of media and formats
Compare, contrast and draw connections among (multi)media resources
Thinking
Critical Thinking: How can students think critically? Students can consider a range of topics such as gathering and organizing information into an argument, recognizing assumptions and bias in perspectives, drawing conclusions and generalizations, understanding counterarguments to see multiple perspectives, identifying trends, etc.
Practise observing carefully in order to recognize problems
Gather and organize relevant information to formulate an argument
Recognize unstated assumptions and bias
Interpret data
Evaluate evidence and arguments
Recognize and evaluate propositions
Draw reasonable conclusions and generalizations
Test generalizations and conclusions
Revise understanding based on new information and evidence
Evaluate and manage risk
Formulate factual, topical, conceptual and debatable questions
Consider ideas from multiple perspectives
Develop contrary or opposing arguments
Analyse complex concepts and projects into their constituent parts and synthesize them to create new understanding
Propose and evaluate a variety of solutions
Identify obstacles and challenges
Use models and simulations to explore complex systems and issues
Identify trends and forecast possibilities
Troubleshoot systems and applications
Creativity and innovation: How can students be creative? Students can consider a range of topics such as brainstorming and mind mapping ideas, creating solutions to complex problems, designing improvements to existing systems or creating new ones, applying existing knowledge to generate new ideas, practicing flexible thinking, etc.
Use brainstorming and visual diagrams to generate new ideas and inquiries
Consider multiple alternatives, including those that might be unlikely or impossible
Create novel solutions to authentic problems
Make unexpected or unusual connections between objects and/or ideas
Design improvements to existing machines, media and technologies
Design new machines, media and technologies
Make guesses, ask “what if” questions and generate testable hypotheses
Apply existing knowledge to generate new ideas, products or processes
Create original works and ideas; use existing works and ideas in new ways
Practise flexible thinking—develop multiple opposing, contradictory and complementary arguments
Practise visible thinking strategies and techniques
Generate metaphors and analogies
Transferring Skills: How can students transfer skills and knowledge among disciplines? Students can consider a range of topics such as applying effective learning strategies from one discipline to another, comparing their conceptual understanding across multiple disciplines, combining knowledge and understanding to create new solutions, etc.
Use effective learning strategies in subject groups and disciplines
Apply skills and knowledge in unfamiliar situations
Inquire in different contexts to gain a different perspective
Compare conceptual understanding across multiple subject groups and disciplines
Make connections between subject groups and disciplines
Combine knowledge, understanding and skills to create products or solutions
Transfer current knowledge to learning of new technologies
Change the context of an inquiry to gain different perspectives